It’s been some time since I’ve sat down and shared my latest thoughts. But it’s December, it’s cold in Wisconsin and I have time. Today I wanted to address two articles I came across, one in a 1992 Golf Magazine (The X Factor) and the other, a 1994 Golf Digest (Ben Hogan’s Secret) plus give you an idea of how to make your game better for 2025.
Jim McClean penned an article thirty two years ago highlighting the importance of maximizing the differential between a player’s shoulder turn and hip turn. The wider the gap between the two, the further the player hit the ball. He termed it the X Factor. It made sense. Remember, the technology used in 1992 was no where near what we have today.
I don’t dispute McClean’s hypothesis regarding this type of swing mechanics. I kept the idea in the back of my mind when I was teaching during those years. I used it myself in my swing. However the fact that fifty-somethings sitting behind a desk 40+ hours a week have little chance of attaining this move was not seriously addressed. This article should have been titled — “The X Factor — Tour Players Only”.
I’ve had back problems throughout my career. Went under the knife five years ago to clean up a disc in my lower lumbar. Golfers with back pain can entertain those who will listen about the trials and travails of finding a pain free solution. I always worked to keep my left foot planted during my backswing, much like the X Factor advised. Can’t say that this caused my condition but it probably didn’t help.
This year I focused on better hip rotation and allowing my left foot to raise slightly during my backswing. Like all players, when I executed the move properly I had great success. The distance on my shots increased as well as my accuracy. I have no idea what my X Factor differential was during this time. Didn’t care. All I knew was the shots were struck better, the results were remarkably improved and I didn’t experience any tightness in my lower back.
Working with older players these days I tend to promote more movement of the knees and hips in order for them to swing their club behind them. Rather than resistance I want my students to feel freedom of movement. Most importantly, I don’t want them to hurt themselves playing this game.
No doubt golf today hardly resembles that played in 1992. Equipment is better, players are in excellent shape due to individualized fitness regimens, and power combined with a deft short game is the formula for success. Yet these days you also have more players incurring injuries. Jordan Spith and Tony Finau recently had surgery to address issues. I don’t recall Palmer, Nicklaus, Trevino or Watson ever missing significant time from the Tour due to injury.
Now I’m not saying the X Factor is a poor concept, rather I’m advising in the world of golf instruction, especially these days, it’s buyer beware. I believe most golfers have egos that from time to time allow them to get out over their skis so to speak. They believe they can swing like a Tour player. It’s necessary to have an effective filter when it comes to absorbing golf instruction because many of the articles and podcasts you come across may not be applicable to your ability. Be realistic when evaluating your capabilities with a golf club.
Jim McClean is a fine golf instructor. I’ve attended a couple of clinics he conducted many years ago. He’s bright, informative and communicates ideas that are easily understandable. He’s has much more to offer than the X Factor. And that’s the secret.
Speaking of secrets, has anyone ever conclusively pinpointed Hogan’s? The March 1994 issue of Golf Digest focused on his movements by having his peers comment on what they thought was the key. Ten men offered ten different opinions on the secret. Whether it was his right elbow, right hand, left hand and arm, ball position, cupped left wrist at the top, you can decide what was the secret.
I love all things Hogan. He was an iconic, lonely figure who gravitated to a game that allowed only him to figure out a way to succeed. Professional golf in those days didn’t reward the unexceptional. If you didn’t play well you couldn’t earn a livelihood. This was why so many playing professionals were also club professionals managing the golf operations for country club members. Hogan garnered some success by 1946 although his nemesis, the low darting, duck hook was still a part of his game. Then, as the story goes, he had an idea while lying in bed one night. Having left the Tour that fall he hadn’t touched a club for three days. Imagine Ben Hogan not practicing!
The next morning he went to the range ready to incorporate his new swing thought. Dreading that his hook would return Hogan was astonished to see shots flying off the club high into the Texas sky with a hint of a fade. The harder he hit it, the better the result. Here was a man, raised dirt poor in Dublin, Texas, learning the hardest game on his own, determined to not have it beat him. You know how the story ends.
Hogan’s secret is not exclusive. It is not mechanical or magical. It is not something others can not possess. All of us have the ability to garner it. Whatever the field of play, sport or business, successful individuals know the secret. It is simply this — to persevere and never accept defeat. Use one’s mind to discover concepts that lead to answers and accomplishments others choose not to pursue. To never give up trying. That was Hogan’s secret. It worked for him and it has worked for many others.
My last thought focuses on game improvement. It’s simple, not a secret at all.
Since half of your strokes occur on the greens doesn’t it make sense to practice putting more than say, your driver? If you average 36+ putts per round would you welcome the opportunity to shave 6-8 strokes off your score? I hope your answer is yes.
Big Moss Golf can unlock this possibility for you. They manufacture the finest putting greens available. I have two of them in my studio. Rather than stick a load of cash into a driver you’ll only hit 12-14 times per round, invest in a better way of shooting lower scores. Contact my friend Tony Persico @ 877-244-6677 and tell him you want to lower your scores with Big Moss. You will play better. Perfect for a wonderful Christmas gift you can use 365 days of the year.
Check them out at http://bigmoss.com